Pergolas vs. Patio Covers: Pros & Cons

By Christopher Olson, EA | May 22, 2025
pergolas and decking

Pergolas vs. Patio Covers: What’s Right for Your Backyard in Mobile, AL?

When it comes to transforming your outdoor space, the question isn’t just “what can I build?” It’s “what fits my lifestyle, budget, backyard, and vibe?”

In the battle of pergolas vs. patio covers, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer—only the right structure for your shade goals, aesthetic dreams, and maybe how much sunburn you’re willing to risk during shrimp season.

Let’s break it down, Mobile-style

 

🌴 First Things First: What Are They?

Pergola: The Classy Skeleton

A pergola is an open-air structure made of vertical posts and cross-beams—usually topped with slats, louvers, or even vines if you're feeling fancy. It doesn’t fully block the sun, but it filters it beautifully and creates the perfect vibe for sipping sweet tea or bourbon with style.

Think: backyard centerpiece meets garden runway.

Patio Cover: The Practical Protector

A patio cover (sometimes called an awning or roof extension) is a solid roofed structure that fully shields you from rain and direct sunlight. It can be attached to your home or freestanding, and it’s typically built to match the existing architecture.

Think: shade fortress. Rain or shine, party on.

Back to Top

☀️ Mobile Weather Says: “Pick Wisely”

Here in Mobile, we know:

  • The sun is strong

  • The humidity is clingy

  • The afternoon storms roll in like clockwork

So, whether you’re grilling, chilling, or trying not to fry your vinyl cushions, you want a structure that’s up to the challenge.

Back to Top

🧱 Let's Compare the Contenders

🏆 Style & Aesthetics

  • Pergola: Clean, modern, romantic. Works great for layering lighting, hanging plants, or letting wisteria climb like it owns the place.
    Pro: Instant design flex.
    Con: Doesn’t match every home style.

  • Patio Cover: More functional, more classic. Can be made to match the house roofline or siding for a seamless look.
    Pro: Feels like an extension of the house.
    Con: Can feel a bit “utility” if not styled right.

🏁 Winner: Pergola, for drama. Patio cover, for cohesion.

Back to Top

💸 Cost Considerations

  • Pergola: Typically less expensive, especially for pressure-treated wood or aluminum kits. Custom wood or steel? You’ll spend more, but still usually under a full cover.

    • Entry range: $2,500–$6,000

    • Custom high-end: $8,000–$15,000+

  • Patio Cover: Costs more due to framing, roofing materials, potential permits, and integration with your house. However, it often adds more resale value due to functionality.

    • Entry range: $5,000–$12,000

    • Custom high-end: $15,000–$25,000+

🏁 Winner: Pergola for affordability. Patio cover for ROI.

Back to Top

🛠 Maintenance

  • Pergola: Wood needs sealing or staining every few years. Metal or vinyl options are lower maintenance. Leaves and bird bombs? Well, that’s part of the charm.
    More aesthetic upkeep than structural.

  • Patio Cover: Typically more durable. With the right roofing material (shingles or metal), maintenance is minimal. But bugs and mildew still love the Gulf Coast, so keep it clean.
    More durable, more work up front, but less fuss long-term.

🏁 Winner: Patio cover for durability. Pergola wins if you want a lower-commitment project.

Back to Top

🔥 How You Use It: Functionality First

Let’s talk about how you live in your backyard.

✅ Pergola is perfect if you:

  • Want a visually striking structure

  • Plan to grill under the stars

  • Like partial sun while you lounge

  • Want a space for lights, plants, or privacy curtains

  • Are okay with ducking inside when it rains

✅ Patio Cover is perfect if you:

  • Want to hang out year-round, rain or shine

  • Plan to mount a ceiling fan or TV

  • Host big gatherings

  • Need real shade and shelter

  • Want to add square footage (and value) to your home

Back to Top

💡 The Landscape Experts' Hot Take

We say: You can’t go wrong—but you can go smarter.

A pergola might be your backyard’s statement piece.
A patio cover might be your outdoor living room.

And in some cases? Why not both?

We’ve helped clients build gorgeous hybrid spaces: a pergola over the firepit, a patio cover over the outdoor kitchen. You don’t have to choose one look for your whole yard—just the right one for the right zone.

Back to Top

🧰 Bonus Tips from Your Licensed Structural Landscaping Pros

  • Permits matter. Here in Mobile, some structures require city approval. We’ve got you covered—literally and legally.

  • Think resale. A well-built patio cover adds serious value, especially in a hot market.

  • Match your lifestyle. Love plants? Pergola. Hate bugs? Patio cover with screened enclosure.

  • Budget wisely. If funds are tight, start with a pergola—and add a cover later.

  • Ask about upgrades. We install privacy screens, misting fans, lighting, and even retractable roofs.

Back to Top

🏁 Final Showdown Scorecard

Feature Pergola Patio Cover
Style ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐⭐
Rain Protection ⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Cost ⭐⭐⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐
Maintenance ⭐⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐⭐
Resale Value ⭐⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐⭐
All-Season Use ⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Installation Time ⭐⭐⭐⭐ ⭐⭐

 

Back to Top

📞 Ready to Build the Backyard You Deserve?

Whether you're Team Pergola or Team Patio Cover, The Landscape Experts are here to build it right—strong, stylish, and built to last. We’re not just landscapers—we’re Licensed Structural Contractors, which means every board, beam, and bolt is installed with care, code, and confidence.

Have questions? Drop us a line.

Posted in Landscaping